Performance-Based Assessment to Measure Understanding

Performance-based assessment, which became a popular alternative to multiple choice tests in the 1990s, has been overshadowed by the recent emphasis on standardized tests. More recently, however, schools are seeking more authentic measures of student learning, and performance-based assessments are making a comeback. Notable author and education consultant, Jay McTighe, defines a performance task as “any learning activity or assessment that asks students to perform to demonstrate their knowledge, understanding and proficiency.” While most performance tasks tend to be focused in areas of the arts and career technology, McTighe argues that performance tasks should be used for all subjects at all grade levels. Performance tasks allow students to be assessed on their understanding of the content and subject matter, requiring them to use higher order thinking skills to demonstrate their learning.

Patricia Hilliard’s recent article, Performance-Based Assessment: Reviewing the Basics, highlights the essential components of a performance-based assessment. In addition to meeting the standards, the assessment should also be:

1. Complex
2. Authentic
3. Process/product-oriented
4. Open-ended
5. Time-bound

Grant Wiggins and Jay McTighe’s book, Understanding by Design, is an excellent resource for getting started with performance-based assessment. In this book, they encourage teachers to start their planning with the assessment and then work backwards from there to determine what to teach. Hilliard recommends that teachers create performance-based assessments for their students based on this "backward design" process. Below are some suggestions for getting started:

1. Identify goals of the performance-based assessment
2. Select the appropriate course standards
3. Review assessments and identify learning gaps
4. Design the scenario
5. Gather or create materials
6. Develop a learning plan

Pepper provides a wide range of courses for teachers that allow for creative and authentic assessment opportunities. As you participate in Pepper's online learning community discuss with peers and determine ways to create performance-based assessments for your students. Be sure to check out our wide range of Pepper Courses to further your own professional growth.

Sign up to receive "The Big Idea" directly to your email each time it's updated. To do this, simply add your email under "Follow PepperPCG Posts by E-mail!" to the right.